Blog

Five things that show up in nearly every law firm digital audit


Five, in nearly every one: cookie banners that break return-visitor reporting, GA4 events configured to flatter the numbers, an insights section inflating bounce rates, hosting that costs more than it should, and a home page built for partners rather than clients. In one firm a single misconfigured event inflated reported conversions by 48%; in another, hosting at £530 a month was matched by UK providers at £89 to £249. Each can be checked on your own site in an afternoon.

Are cookie banners distorting your analytics?

Often, yes. Five years of digital audits inside law firms, of different sizes, practice areas, agencies and CMS platforms, turn up the same five issues. The first is a cookie banner that meets the letter of the ICO guidance and ignores its spirit: too dense, with a click flow so complex that mobile users bounce off it before reaching the content. Because their consent never sticks, Google Analytics treats them as new on every visit, so the new-versus-returning ratio is broken and every report using return-visitor rate misleads. Check your returning-user percentage, then look at the banner on mobile: more than two scroll-lengths or more than three buttons means you have the problem. Simplify it, consider a managed product such as CookieYes, and stop reporting return-visitor rate until it is fixed.

Are your GA4 events configured correctly?

Almost every firm I audit has at least one event set up in a way that flatters the numbers. In one firm a single misconfigured event was inflating reported conversion volume by 48% across its UK and US sites, unnoticed because the agency's monthly report kept showing growth. Look at each event's volume over the last month: anything above 5% of total events should have a definition you understand. Ask the agency for a list of every active event and its trigger, and question anything that does not make sense.

Is the insights section dragging your engagement metrics down?

Probably. A long article ranks on a long-tail search, a reader finds it, reads it and leaves. Across two thousand articles that produces high bounce rates and exits, which agency reports call low-quality traffic when it is readers who got what they came for. Filter analytics to the insights section and compare its bounce rate with the rest of the site; it is likely to account for under 5% of conversions and over 30% of bounces. Add links from articles to relevant service pages and lawyer biographies, replace "back to insights" with "find a lawyer" or "request a call", and track the change for sixty days.

Is the firm paying too much for hosting?

Often. Many law firm sites sit on dedicated hosting that suited the traffic five years ago and does not now. In one engagement the firm was paying £530 a month; after review the same performance was available from three UK providers at between £89 and £249 a month, and the firm moved, using part of the saving to pay for a content writer. If you pay more than £200 a month without a transactional site behind a login, get three quotes, and review hosting every two years, because contracts auto-renew and providers rarely offer a cheaper deal.

Is the home page built for partners or for clients?

For partners, in most firms: every practice area, sector, office and award, a values statement, testimonials and a news ticker, because every partner who lobbied for visibility got it. Visitors see eight options, cannot tell which is theirs and leave. Time how long it takes on mobile to find the route to your most profitable practice area; more than five seconds means you have the problem. Put two clear paths above the fold, such as services for individuals and services for businesses, with everything else one click in. In one engagement the home page redesign was the single biggest change behind a 190% year-on-year rise in online enquiries. If you find three or more of these five on your own site, commission a proper audit, because the fixes are individually cheap and compound together.

Related evidence: How a mid size regional UK law firm grew online enquiries by 190% without rebuilding their website. Earlier in this journey: What counts as a lead? Most law firm marketing reports can’t tell you.

Questions people ask

How much should a law firm pay for website hosting?

If it is more than £200 a month without a transactional site behind a login, get three competing quotes, and review hosting every two years because most contracts auto-renew.

When is a full law firm digital audit worth commissioning?

When three or more of these five problems show up on your own site. The fixes are individually cheap, and together they compound.



Not sure where to start?

Most clients begin with a conversation. No pitch, no hard sell.

Just a straightforward discussion about where you are and whether I can help.

Book a free 30-minute call

We handle your details in line with our privacy policy.